I picked up that the UK variable VAT rate might cause a lot more work, so I thought it was worth adding that ALL FOOD AND DRINK IS STANDARD RATED SO I DON’T THINK WE NEED TO BOTHER HAVING A REDUCED RATE VAT CATEGORY IN OFN.
Although you are right on this I think it will be important to include this reduced rate in the long term. It’s largely for things like soap, toothpaste, shampoo, for which there is scope for local production that I think works well within Food Hubs.
Perhaps we can just make this a non-urgent feature, the dual rate in UK VAT.
Yep good plan, I’ve put it in as TODO in the above, we’ll see how this works, but kind of collecting up issues that can be moved to github when they’re more in the ‘let’s do now’ category . . (info mgmt overhaul in progress
Will talk to @RohanM about the ‘mark-up’ vs ‘admin’ in standup this morning. It’s slightly tricky, because you could use the ‘per order’ fees to pull it out and not include in tax - but they’re called ‘admin & handling’ on the front at the moment, and there isn’t a ‘% per order’ currently (the % is calculated per product)! How much does it matter what it’s called in the system?
For later consideration, would it be a case of actually having two tax rates to choose from, and would the reduced rate also apply to fees / shipping etc or they would still be the standard VAT rate?
Kirsten and I have had a quick chat, and we’re thinking that the easiest way to choose which fees are taxed would be to specify a tax category for each fee when defining them. That would be a lot more explicit, rather than having implicit knowledge that particular fee types are taxed and others aren’t.
When creating fees that attract tax, we’d need to alert enterprises that aren’t registered for sales tax since this is a contradictory setup.
Sorry it has taken me so long to reply to this. Picking up Kirsten’s questions first:
It’s slightly tricky, because you could use the ‘per order’ fees to pull it out and not include in tax - but they’re called ‘admin & handling’ on the front at the moment, and there isn’t a ‘% per order’ currently (the % is calculated per product)! How much does it matter what it’s called in the system? For later consideration, would it be a case of actually having two tax rates to choose from, and would the reduced rate also apply to fees / shipping etc or they would still be the standard VAT rate?
I think all that matters to Stroudco is that there is not an item on the shopping screen or customer invoice (or any other report) that is called ‘admin fee’ or ‘handling fee’ or anything similar.
It is fine that the % is calculated per product - as long as that percentage can be discounted for customers who are either doing voluntary work or paying a ‘membership’ standing order.
Yes the current Stroudco system allows the user to choose from one of 3 options (zero, reduced or standard tax rates) although there is currently no use for the reduced rate. Yes fees/shipping would attract standard rate tax.
Moving on to Rohan’s point:
the easiest way to choose which fees are taxed would be to specify a tax category for each fee when defining them. That would be a lot more explicit, rather than having implicit knowledge that particular fee types are taxed and others aren’t. > When creating fees that attract tax, we’d need to alert enterprises that aren’t registered for sales tax since this is a contradictory setup.
This sounds fine as long as enterprises can change the tax category in the future if the tax rates change. I agree we need to make it clear to enterprises that even if they are not VAT registered, that because Stroudco IS VAT registered, their products might be liable to VAT. This is the note we put in the Stroudco producer joining form:
- Stroudco is VAT registered. Most food products are not VATable but please check this link to see if your product is VATable: > http://customs.hmrc.gov.uk/channelsPortalWebApp/channelsPortalWebApp.portal?_nfpb=true&_pageLabel=pageLibrary_ShowContent&id=HMCE_CL_000118&propertyType=document#downloadopt > If you sell VATable products through Stroudco and if you are not VAT registered, Stroudco will deduct 20% VAT from the sale price of any VATable product before paying you the balance. Please bear this in mind when setting your prices.
ok people. The first tranch of this is in staging ready to test. I’ve included some notes above about how I’ve done the set-up and recommend someone goes through and sets up UK staging how you want it.
It looks to me like the different tax rates will be no problem, you just set two and the producer / hub selects which one applies when setting up the product
The issue about the mark-up I think we probably getting around by creating another fee type called ‘mark-up’ or by doing 2nd dot point here
Just to chime in with a quick question regarding GST on Australian OFN, it’s now applicable to products, but I can’t seem to find a way to apply it to enterprise fees. I noted that tax on fees was mentioned above, but wasn’t sure if it was in place as part of the latest update? (if so, can someone point me in the right direction?)
For instance, any delivery fees we would charge, would need to include GST (and I guess show that in the customer order and invoices - as noted in the set-up at the top of this discussion “Each of the fees charged, marked as “(inc. GST)” when GST is included in it”)
yep, that’s not in yet - setting GST on fees is in staging, will come through this week.
I think also that we might want to override how Matt did the shipping tax (e.g. set at instance level) and just allow the Enterprise who’s creating the shipping method also choose whether it includes tax or not? @rohan?
thanks Rohan - as soon as this is in UK staging I will set up some tests. thanks for all your work on it.
Hi everyone! About Norway, we will need actually three type of VAT rates… for non-food the regular rate is 25%. Then for food and drinks it’s 15%, and there is a special rate for raw fish which is 11,11%… Some hubs may or may note be VAT registered (but I see we can say true or false). Appart from that we need to go more into testing, but I guess it wouldn’t be so different from what is already done in UK and Australia.
[they can mark products as GST/VAT inclusive, which will then consider that they have 10% etc included in price. [again check - perhaps won’t if super-admin has set tax to not be included]
- Yes, when I made a product with the tax category ‘GST’, 1/11th of the price was split out as GST at checkout. This 1/11th was also pulled out as ‘Sales Tax’ in the Sales Tax report. Conversely, when the tax category was ‘None’ no GST was split out at checkout or in the sales tax report.
[the shipping charge (ie. pickup or to the door delivery) is taken as inclusive of tax [looks like this can be turned on or off in Tax Settings . . check / test]
- Yes, when tax setting ‘shipment including vat’ was ticked, my flat percentage shipping fee was assumed to include 10% GST. This was shown in the Sales Tax report. However, GST on shipping isn’t visible to customers at checkout (whereas tax on products is). When I unticked ‘shipment including vat’ my shipping fee no longer included tax (but the flat % remained unchanged). Reports no longer split GST out of my shipping charge.
[fees can be set to be inclusive of or exclusive of tax]
Yes, my admin fee (coordinator flat %) could be set to GST inclusive (in which case GST was split out in the sales tax report) or not (no GST captured in sales tax report). Admin fee GST was also not visible to the customer.
Hi Myriam - see set-up instructions above - you should be able to easily set up the three tax rates . .
I have a story about cake to verify that some of our thinking about tax is correct:
A producer is registered for GST and is supplying a cake.
The cake attracts GST, and its GST-inclusive price is $20.
A hub that is not registered for GST is selling the cake.
The hub sells the cake for $20 - there is no change to the price.
The hub then registers for GST.
The cake still sells for $20, but now $1.82 of that is charged to the customer as GST, and the hub keeps only $18.18.
If the hub wishes to prevent this shortfall, they must increase the price of the cake to $22.
Would this be the correct behaviour?
Ignore me if i’m asking questions in the middle of your testing.
Will there be anything in the shopfront to show customers which items are GST inclusive (a little asterix or as part of the price breakdown pie chart?)
GST doesn’t show up in the Edit Cart page.
In the checkout & final invoice page, there is currently nothing to show which of the products in the order are attracting the GST - only a final GST amount.
Will GST as a breakdown be included in products reports? - this links to the wishlist concept of keeping a central price list on Xero and importing in to OFN
this is a photo of rohan shortly after he announced “I think I’ve finished the QE#%@KJ tax” … he didn’t swear, I added that for effect.
We’ve got a bunch of stuff queued up but aiming to have the whole shebang in staging2 tomorrow afternoon. so prepare your testing data please
ok people, sales tax as described above is now in Aus staging and will be pushed to production in v0.8.1
Be most excellent if you can test it lots. We’ve done quite a bit but obviously is complicated, so the more eyes the better!
NB. there are a bunch of improvements that are [TODO]. These are nice to have, but not critical to it working so going onto the backburner
Bloody marvellous @RohanM
Thanks for all your work on this
Yes - correct behaviour re cake pricing
I made some changes in the wiki as it was not clear for me that you had to create a tax category for each group of products, and in a tax category, the potential different taxe rates are linked only to the different zones…
Hope it’s clearer
@Kirsten: to make it more clear maybe I can replace the screenshots by some from the norwegian instance where we have different tax categories, so that we have a more “complex” example?
fine with me if you replace screenshots with those that illustrate the point